Operate8 min read

MCP exclusion review packet

Every operation still open in the MCP parity inventory, with a proposed disposition.

This packet lists every operation still open in the MCP parity inventory, with a proposed disposition. It was generated from npm run --silent mcp:coverage to help reviewers; it does not record any decision. Automated tooling must not author exclusion records. An exclusion counts only when a named reviewer records it in src/lib/mcp/catalog/review.json. The record needs a date, a rationale of at least 20 characters, and a safe equivalent where one exists. The schema rejects anything else.

Snapshot (2026-11-09): 72 open operations of 325. Proposed: implement 1, exclude 71. Regenerate the inventory before reviewing. The operation IDs, risks and reasons below come from the registry.

How to record a decision

  1. Confirm the operation, its risk class and the current reason in the coverage artifact.
  2. For an exclusion, add an exclusion object to the operation in review.json: reviewer, reviewedAt (YYYY-MM-DD), rationale, and safeEquivalent (or null). Keep its status as DENIED_WITH_REASON or UNSUPPORTED_WITH_REASON.
  3. For an implementation, follow the approval batch process in full-parity delivery. Never re-label an operation to raise coverage.
  4. Run npm run --silent mcp:coverage and the parity unit tests. The artifact reports the reviewed count as reviewedExclusions.

Blocked on a transactional domain command (no durable receipt or single transaction) (1)

Proposed disposition: Implement.

Operation Risk Method Current reason Reviewer Date Decision
updateStatusPage R2 PATCH Not exposed: disabling a page withdraws the public projection before the transaction (a deliberate privacy guarantee) and no-op updates open no transaction, so an approval cannot be recorded atomically with the effect.

Superseded by an approval-gated equivalent (1)

Proposed disposition: Exclude.

Operation Risk Method Current reason Reviewer Date Decision
deleteRunbook R3 DELETE Proposed exclusion (pending named review): native rules forbid deleting a runbook with published versions; use archiveRunbook (approval-gated) instead.

Exceeds MCP request bounds (1)

Proposed disposition: Exclude.

Operation Risk Method Current reason Reviewer Date Decision
uploadStatusPageAsset R2 POST Proposed exclusion (pending named review): a base64 image body of up to 2.8 MB exceeds the 64 KiB MCP request bound by design; upload through the native status-page editor.

Response or binding unsafe for a model (7)

Proposed disposition: Exclude.

Operation Risk Method Current reason Reviewer Date Decision
cancelReportExport R2 POST Not exposed: cancellation is scoped to the creating API key, and MCP cannot create exports (see createReportExport).
createReportExport R2 POST Not exposed: exports are bound to an API-key row (ReportExport.apiKeyId, NOT NULL foreign key) and MCP principals have none, so an approved export could never be produced or downloaded. Opening report exports needs a non-additive schema change (nullable ReportExport.apiKeyId plus a grant owner). Safe equivalent: queryReportMetrics and getReportMetrics, bounded side-effect-free reads.
createServiceIntegration R2 POST Not exposed: the response discloses the new integration key in clear, so it needs a rotation-style workflow that never returns the secret to an agent.
downloadReportDashboardData R2 GET Proposed exclusion (pending named review): bulk data download; agents should use getReportDashboardData.
downloadReportExport R2 GET Proposed exclusion (pending named review): file export bound to API-key rows MCP principals do not have.
getReportExport R2 GET Proposed exclusion (pending named review): exports are bound to API-key rows MCP principals do not have.
previewRunbookExecutionRerun R2 POST Not exposed: the preview returns a rerun authorization token that would let the holder start execution; a model must never receive it. Proposed exclusion (pending named review); safe equivalent is runbook_prepare_execution with native review.

Credential and secret material (24)

Proposed disposition: Exclude.

Operation Risk Method Current reason Reviewer Date Decision
activateRunbookSigningIdentity R3 POST Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.
configureNotificationProvider R3 PUT Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.
createRunbookAgentEnrollment R3 POST Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.
createRunbookSecret R3 POST Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.
getIntegrationCredentialState R3 GET Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.
getNotificationProvider R3 GET Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.
getNotificationProviderDiagnostics R3 GET Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.
getRunbookAgentEnrollment R3 GET Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.
getRunbookSecret R3 GET Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.
grantRunbookSecret R3 POST Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.
issueServiceAccountToken R3 POST Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.
listNotificationProviders R3 GET Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.
listRunbookSecretGrants R3 GET Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.
listRunbookSecretUsage R3 GET Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.
listRunbookSecrets R3 GET Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.
listRunbookSigningIdentities R3 GET Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.
retireRunbookSigningIdentity R3 POST Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.
revokeRunbookSecretGrant R3 DELETE Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.
revokeServiceAccountToken R3 DELETE Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.
rotateIntegrationCredentials R3 POST Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.
rotateRunbookSecret R3 POST Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.
rotateWebPushKeys R3 POST Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.
stageRunbookSigningIdentity R3 POST Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.
testNotificationProvider R3 POST Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.

Identity and access administration (11)

Proposed disposition: Exclude.

Operation Risk Method Current reason Reviewer Date Decision
administerUser R3 PATCH Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.
createServiceAccount R3 POST Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.
createUserInvitation R3 POST Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.
deleteServiceAccount R3 DELETE Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.
getServiceAccount R3 GET Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.
getUserAdministration R3 GET Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.
getUserDependencies R3 GET Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.
getUserInvitation R3 GET Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.
getUserInvitationPolicy R3 GET Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.
listServiceAccounts R3 GET Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.
renewUserInvitation R3 POST Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.

Runbook execution infrastructure (agents and pools) (16)

Proposed disposition: Exclude.

Operation Risk Method Current reason Reviewer Date Decision
checkRunbookAgentPoolDeletion R3 GET Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.
createRunbookAgentPool R3 POST Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.
deleteRunbookAgentPool R3 DELETE Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.
getRunbookAgent R3 GET Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.
getRunbookAgentConfiguration R3 GET Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.
getRunbookAgentPolicyStatus R3 GET Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.
getRunbookAgentPool R3 GET Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.
listRunbookAgentPoolMembers R3 GET Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.
listRunbookAgentPools R3 GET Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.
listRunbookAgents R3 GET Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.
removeRunbookAgentPoolMember R3 DELETE Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.
retireRunbookAgentPool R3 POST Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.
revokeRunbookAgent R3 POST Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.
setRunbookAgentPoolMember R3 PUT Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.
updateRunbookAgentConfiguration R3 PATCH Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.
updateRunbookAgentPool R3 PATCH Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.

Audit evidence (3)

Proposed disposition: Exclude.

Operation Risk Method Current reason Reviewer Date Decision
createAuditExport R3 POST Not exposed: an audit export is owned by an ApiKey row (AuditExport.apiKeyId, NOT NULL foreign key) and an MCP principal has none, so an approved export could never be created, read back or downloaded; the file carries actor emails and IP addresses the MCP projection must remove, so it would not be the reviewed artefact anyway. Opening it needs a non-additive schema change (nullable apiKeyId plus a grant owner). Safe equivalent: listAuditLogs (sensitive read, paged, email and IP removed).
downloadAuditExport R3 GET Not exposed: downloads an unredacted audit file (actor emails, IP addresses) owned by an ApiKey row that MCP principals do not have (see createAuditExport). Safe equivalent: listAuditLogs.
getAuditExport R3 GET Not exposed: reads an audit export owned by an ApiKey row that MCP principals do not have (see createAuditExport). Safe equivalent: listAuditLogs.

Personal data and personal paging settings (5)

Proposed disposition: Exclude.

Operation Risk Method Current reason Reviewer Date Decision
getMyNotificationPreferences R3 GET Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.
getStatusPageSubscriber R2 GET Proposed exclusion (pending named review): subscriber personal data; use getStatusPageSubscriberStats.
listStatusPageSubscribers R2 GET Proposed exclusion (pending named review): subscriber personal data; use getStatusPageSubscriberStats.
removeStatusPageSubscriber R3 DELETE Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.
updateMyNotificationPreferences R3 PATCH Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.

Configuration that can carry endpoint secrets or access controls (3)

Proposed disposition: Exclude.

Operation Risk Method Current reason Reviewer Date Decision
getChatOpsConfiguration R2 GET Proposed exclusion (pending named review): ChatOps configuration contains webhook URLs whose path is itself a credential.
getIntegration R2 GET Proposed exclusion (pending named review): integration configuration can carry endpoint secrets; use listIntegrations and getIntegrationUsage.
getStatusPagePrivacy R3 GET Credential, personal-data or infrastructure boundary restricted to native administration.

Last updated for v2.2.0

Edit this page on GitHub